Book review: ‘The Old Straight Track’ by Alfred Watkins

The Old Straight Track (1)Quite possibly my favourite book of all time… I’ve been meaning to review this for so long!

When Alfred Watkins was riding around the Herefordshire hills in the early 1920s, he pulled up his horse to gaze across the landscape, and he had a sudden revelation.

In his vision, every landmark, whether natural or man-made, was linked by a network of straight lines, which he saw as glowing wires laid out over the surface of the land.  The lines passed through hill summits and cairns, linking church spires, prehistoric settlements and burial sites, old encampments and sacred monuments.   Following the route that they took were trackways, straight roads that had been ancient and well trodden long before the coming of the Romans, along which the first settlers of this country would have travelled by day and night, their eyes keenly aware of waymarkers that we, in our age of all-seeing technology, are now almost blind to.

Although the name didn’t come to him in that instant, Watkins called these tracks ‘ley lines’.

A keen amateur archaeologist, Watkins was spurred into action, studying maps and undertaking many months of research in the field.  This was his native country, and he already knew it like the back of his hand;   he soon discovered countless alignments, far more than could conceivably exist through coincidence alone.

Watkins revealed his theory in an address to the Woolhope Club, an amateur archaeological society in Hereford, of which he was a member.  He followed it up with an essay entitled ‘Early British Trackways’ and then, in 1925, with a book called ‘The Old Straight Track – its Mounds, Beacons, Moats, Sites and Mark Stones’.

Callow (1)There are few books which truly merit the word ‘iconic’, but in my opinion, ‘The Old Straight Track’ is one of them.  Nearly 90 years after its publication, it continues to open the eyes of readers so that they see the landscape in an entirely new light;  as John Michell rightly puts it, writing in the Foreword, for many people the book “awoke, as it were, the memory of a half familiar truth.”   When I first read the book for myself, getting on for 20 years ago now, this was certainly my own experience.

Not that Watkins’ theories were greeted with widespread acclaim – far from it, in fact.  Few people took his ideas seriously, and he became the subject of ridicule.  This was an age that wouldn’t tolerate alternative interpretations of history, and the horrified reaction of many traditional historians probably masked an underlying instinct of fear.

But let’s not dwell on them!   Watkins might have been a little hazy about time periods, as modern archaeologists have pointed out, but he was writing long before the advent of radiocarbon dating.  In his descriptions, it’s easy to hear the voice of a man so in tune with the countryside, so observant and appreciative of the heritage that he was exploring.

Introducing the concept of ley lines, Watkins paints an irresistible picture of rural bliss:

“The outdoor man, away on a cross-country tramp, taking in the uplands, lingering over his midday sandwich on the earthwork of some hill-top camp, will look all round ‘to get the lay of the land.’”

The distinctive wooded summit of Bromlow Callow in south Shropshire. Photo courtesy of Shane at thebiggestlittlehills.com

The distinctive wooded summit of Bromlow Callow in south Shropshire. Photo courtesy http://www.thebiggestlittlehills.com

And sometimes his descriptions are flavoured by his job as a travelling representative for his family’s brewery business:

“The air – playing down from the Forest – is like wine all over Radnor Bottom, and folk from the more relaxing plains of Herefordshire come for a brace-up to quarters such as ‘The Eagle’ or ‘King’s Arms’ at New Radnor…”

He goes on to describe the construction of ancient mounds, many of which have now been lost through agriculture and development, but which would have served as sighting points along ley lines;   he looks at ‘mark stones’, ancient monuments ranging from standing stones to the remnants of wayside crosses, some of which were inscribed with grooves running down their length, which intrigued him enough to try inserting a broomstick into them, to see if they were designed to hold an early theodolite or surveyor’s pole;   and water sight points, either natural fords in rivers, or man-made moats or ‘flashes’.

And he then adds a fascinating third dimension in the form of word derivation and place names:  in England a ‘flash’ is a regional term for a pool, but of course it is also a sudden burst of light;  the word ‘moat’ can also be spelled ‘mote’, meaning a tiny speck that catches the sunlight;  and ‘ey’ (which you can’t help but link with ‘eye’) is an old name for an island.  Were moats and flashes originally seen as way markers, reflecting the sun (or moon) light when viewed from a certain point on a path, reassuring a traveller that he was on the right track?   Were they designed to mirror the night-time flames of a distant beacon?

Cold Aston in Gloucestershire, by Philip Halling via Wikimedia

Cold Aston in Gloucestershire, by Philip Halling via Wikimedia

Watkins examines place names with elements of ‘cole’, ‘coal’ and ‘coel’;   those containing ‘black’, also found in ‘blache’ and ‘blake’;   and ‘dod’, ‘tot’ and ‘tut’ (in Welsh, ‘twt’), which are found in names such as Doddington, Dodderhill, Totnes and Toothill.

About the ‘cole’ names and their variants, which are far too ancient and widespread to derive from any coal-mining activities, Watkins gives archaic definitions of ‘coel’ which referred to omens and divination, and cites the old term ‘cole-prophet’ to describe a wizard or sorcerer.  Following this train of thought, he suggests a long-lost practice that has left our landscape littered with names like Coleshill, Colebatch, Colebrook and many ‘cold’ variants like Cold Ash, Coldborough and Cold Harbour.  He says:

“The general conclusion is that the Coleman, who gave his name to all kinds of points and places on the tracks, was a head-man in making them, and probably worked from the Colehills, using beacon fire for marking out the ley.”

When you find yourself suddenly enlightened about place names close to your own roots – in my case, Cold Hatton in Shropshire – you do almost literally ‘see the light’.

Track near Uckington, Shropshire, by Richard Law via Wikimedia

Track near Uckington, Shropshire, by Richard Law via Wikimedia

The same theory is applied to ‘black‘ or ‘blake‘ (which, intriguingly, Watkins also allies with ‘bleach‘ and ‘bleak’).  This has little to do with our modern understanding of ‘black’, but may instead have referred to a gleaming light.  And as for the ‘dod‘, ‘tot’ or ‘toot‘ hills, he suggests that they preserve the memory of the ‘dodman’, the man who worked with two long rods, moving them back and forth while keeping a number of distant landmarks in sight, ensuring that sighting mounds and stones were erected in precisely the right points along a track.

Pondering the old folk name of ‘dodman‘ to describe a garden snail, used by Charles Dickens in ‘David Copperfield’, Watkins matter-of-factly recounts another of his lightbulb moments:

“The sight of a snail out for a walk one warm moist morning solved the problem.  He carries on his head the dod-man’s implements, the two sighting staves.”

Although the hilltop forts, churches, castles and mark stones provide the substance, for me it is the old words that form the star around which Watkins weaves his golden web of magic – and it really is magic, because I have found myself drawn back in, once again feeling the hairs rising on the back of my neck, just from re-reading his chapter on place names and knowing – just knowing, somewhere in the very back of my mind – that he has stumbled on a very deep and ancient truth.

Old Radnor Church, which Watkins says was traditionally a beacon church, by Philip Halling via Wikimedia

Old Radnor Church, which Watkins says was traditionally a beacon church, by Philip Halling via Wikimedia

With our modern mindset we might take issue with Watkins’ interpretation of his discoveries… but I feel that sometimes we approach history with too much science and not enough instinct, overlaying an almost-forgotten intuition with an ever-growing reliance on statistics and computer analysis.   What Watkins did was go back to the land, and speak to the old folks (who have now long since gone, and their families probably moved away);   he allowed himself to see and listen with his heart, and he wasn’t afraid to smash the china urns of accepted knowledge.   He was a true visionary, and I would love to have talked to him – better still, walked with him along some of the ridges that he knew so well.

‘The Old Straight Track’ is a snapshot of a countryside that has now changed probably beyond Watkins’ recognition;   it’s a humbly-written explanation of an idea that is as revolutionary as it is brilliant;   and it’s a bottomless mine of gems, little nuggets of enlightenment that make you feel that you’re the first to discover them.  There are so many more I could tell you about, but I don’t want to spoil the pleasure!

The Old Straight Track (2)I realise that ley lines might be verging too far into the ‘hippy dippy’ side of history for some people, and in that case this book probably isn’t for you.  But if you are willing to entertain an idea that might have more than a grain of truth in it, I can only recommend that you buy yourself a copy, and allow yourself the time to read and enjoy it.   And if you’ve already read it, you will know for sure what I’m talking about, and I’m willing to bet it’s one of your most treasured books.

My own copy, which was purchased second-hand, also contains loose newspaper cuttings from the 1970s about ley lines in East Anglia and one about a Victorian mole trap that someone had dug up while out rabbiting.   Who could ask for more?   If I had to save just one book from my bookshelf I’d be distressed, but I’d choose this one.

Ley hunters…

Although it was initially greeted with derision, Watkins’ ley line theory gained enough followers during his lifetime for him to establish a society called The Old Straight Track Club, which he actively participated in until his death in 1935 at the age of 80.   The papers of the Club are in Hereford’s city museum.

Watkins also unknowingly lit the fire of a widespread passion for ley hunting that was seized on again in the 1960s and 70s, and whose flames show no signs of going out.  Ancient tracks, energy lines of the earth, angel pathways… however ley lines are interpreted, the concept has a fresh appeal for each successive generation, and that in itself is perhaps a sign that it holds some fundamental truth – and we acknowledge it with an awareness which goes much deeper than logic.

Bromlow Callow in Shropshire. Photo courtesy The Biggest Little Hills www.thebiggestlittlehills.com

Bromlow Callow in Shropshire. Photo courtesy of http://www.thebiggestlittlehills.com

Who was Alfred Watkins?

Alfred WatkinsBorn in 1855 to a wealthy family who owned a flour mill and a brewery, Alfred Watkins was a man ahead of his time.  Quite apart from his revelations about ley lines, he was a keen bee-keeper, a member of the Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings, and a Fellow of the Royal Photographic Society.  He invented the Watkins Bee Meter, an ingenious exposure meter the size of a pocket watch, for use with plate cameras.  If you love vintage photo equipment, take a look on eBay – good examples sometimes come up for sale!

‘The Old Straight Track – Its Mounds, Beacons, Moats, Sites and Mark Stones’ was first published in 1925.  After several re-prints it’s now available from Abacus, ISBN 978-0349137070, RRP £14.99 (paperback, 240 pages).

My thanks to Shane who writes a blog called The Biggest Little Hills, for his kind permission to reproduce his photos of Bromlow Callow in Shropshire.

Comments

  1. Reblogged this on The Biggest Little Hills and commented:
    Fantastic piece, and a fantastic book.

  2. Great blog, and well explained! I read Watkins’ book some years back and had a similar experience to yours: the hairs rising on the back of the neck as my mind absorbed a concept that seemed magical and yet obvious. And yet the “sensible” part of my brain still argues that alignments happen anyway, simply by accident. Nevertheless, alignments of many ancient stone megaliths are clearly visible on Ordnance Survey maps, and the biggest and most obvious ones must have been intentional. I think there is definitely something valid in Alfred Watkins’ theory, even if he only put his finger on part of a larger truth. (And as an American visitor, my 2006 climb to the top of Glastonbury Tor was made more enjoyable by imagining hundreds of converging ley lines at the summit!) Thank you for posting this.

    • Thank you very much! I’m so glad it struck a chord with you. I agree that Watkins probably put his finger on a larger truth – I don’t think he realised at first just how far his theory could be applied. I am envious of your Glastonbury visit! That’s one of the places I would really love to see.

  3. Great post. I remember the hoo-ha about this book in the 70s and when I studied prehistory at Sheffield it was consigned to the ‘lunatic fringe’ school of archaeology. But it’s interesting watching Stuart whatshisname, the landscape-reading archaeologist on Time Team, to see how reading the landscape empathetically, as Watkins seemed to do, can actually provide many fruitful insights about our forebears and why they settled or built monuments where they did. And as for ley lines, I’m quite happy to open minded about them.

    • Thank you! I’m now trying to remember Stuart’s other name! (Ainsworth – looked it up in the end!) He is driven by instinct and I often used to think I would love his job!

  4. I like the sound of this – after all, there’s nothing wrong with being a teeny bit ‘hippy dippy’!

  5. Great Jo, it would be wonderful to get more people reading Watkins again, you’re right there’s a fabulous magic to tune into and it’s sitting there in our landscape and heritage. If you haven’t already, I urge you to read the Merrily Watkins novels from Phil Rickman – very much in the groove, with a Watkins connection. I shall put my copy by the bedside again and have another read.🙂

    PS – we spent a week in a cottage a short stroll from Bromlow Callow a few years ago and did a lot of local walking – that whole area oozes magic, I can still feel it if I close my eyes – if that doesn’t sound too weird.

    • You’re so right, Anny, and I know I’m preaching to the converted with you! 🙂 Thank you for the book recommendation, I had a look online and they look good so I might treat myself!

      Bromlow and everywhere around there is a lovely area – I remember it well, coming from Shropshire myself. Most people don’t know it exists, and so the ‘spell’ feels unbroken. I know what you mean!

    • “Oozes magic” is a fantastic description of the Callow and this area, thank you!

  6. This is fascinating. I didn’t even know that ley lines were a name coined by a single person, rather than having always been known. Mr. Watkins must have been a wonderful man to spend time with.

    I do so agree with you about the danger of new knowledge despising or obliterating the old ways and the old wisdom, or as you so beautifully put it, the ‘deep and ancient truth’. (I wonder if you know the song ‘The Old Ways’ by Loreena McKennit? She is surely the voice of people sympathetic to these things.) Science and academic learning inspire and enthuse me, but we must not dispense with more instinctive wisdom. Like you, I have felt *something* in places like standing stones and barrows (Loch Craignish springs to mind; also the terrifying and unfriendly Rollright Stones) which I do not dismiss for being unable to explain.

    Interestingly, I have been told by several people that the reason the Dunkeld area is stuffed with creative types – musicians, writers, craftspeople, healers – is that the town is sited on the convergence of several ley lines…go figure!

    • Thank you for your lovely comment, and I think you would love the book, in that case! Yes, Watkins would have been a wonderful man to talk to. I will look up Loreena McKennit, whom I’ve never heard of, but she sounds interesting – thank you! And that is fascinating about Dunkeld. If you extend Watkins’ theory further (as many people have) and imagine that ley lines are invisible lines of the Earth’s energy, then there may have been a ‘crossroads’ of these lines on the site of somewhere like the original monastery/church (and who knows why the monastery was founded there? – was there an ancient wisdom that sensed this, and placed an even earlier shrine in that spot?) And I can’t believe that you’ve mentioned the Rollright Stones because on Thursday we’re off down to Oxfordshire and I’ve made a promise to myself that I’ll snatch some time to visit them. I would love to know more about your experience but maybe I should go there with an open mind, and find out afterwards!

    • PS I have just listened to that song – beautiful!

      • I’m so glad you liked it. I love her work. I shall be very interested to hear what you make of the Rollright Stones – let’s compare notes afterwards!

  7. Maia T. says:

    This was an explosive book for me as I began my apprenticeship in shamanism. Though it describes a landscape I didn’t live in at that time, Native Americans have similar things to say about the landscape, especially of the western and southwestern part of the U.S., where I was living. Distance didn’t stop what Watkins said from resonating deeply with me.

    • That’s very interesting to know about the Native Americans, and I am sure they have a gift of ‘seeing’ the landscape in ways that we have since forgotten. How wonderful to have such wisdom. I think Watkins only realised gradually that his theory extended across the whole earth, and just how much it could explain.

  8. Very interesting, a lot of ancient churches are possibly built on ley lines…..apparently. I read it somewhere a long, long time ago. Not sure if its true, but in some churches you do get a sense of ancientness and many are built on the foundations of a building that has been there since almost the beginning of time itself, a place where they would have gathered to pray together…..not sure which god, but they would have prayed to someone. Not some thing I know a lot about, but even since a small child, I have known that ley lines where there, my mother told me about them, she often talked about them when she took us out exploring….should have asked her why….bit late now, unless she read his book🙂

    • This is true, Lynne, and churches were often founded on holy wells, where springs naturally bubbled out of the ground… and of course energy lines often converged at such points. Watkins gives examples of many churches which have springs underneath their altar (Winchester for one). I think he hit on a wisdom that we can all feel and sense, and for me it was as if a long-lost jigsaw was falling into place. A truly amazing book.

  9. I was reading about Watkins’ ley lines a few years ago, and started drawing lines on a map of England. Surprising how many significant points lie on those lines. Glastonbury-Stonehenge-Canterbury is more or less a straight line. I assumed that they were old sight lines for signaling with fires or mirrors (smoke and mirrors).

    • When you start looking at maps, the lines just keep on revealing themselves, as Watkins found. Another of my favourite books is ‘The Pattern of the Past’ by Guy Underwood – he was a dowser back in the 1960s and did lots of investigations into sites such as Stonehenge, where a number of ley lines converge. For me, his findings back up Watkins’ theory so well. Thank you for your comment, and for re-blogging this!

  10. A truly wonderful book – my most treasured one too! – and a great review. Alfred Watkins didn’t just come up with a new theory, he came up with an almost entirely new way of looking at the landscape – which many modern archaeologists have taken on board, whether or not they would recognise the similarities. It’s also worth remembering that the ‘hippy-dippy'(!) theories around UFOs, ghosts and so on came well after Watkins’ death – who knows what he would have made of them.

    Have you read Ron Shoesmith’s books about Alfred Watkins? They give a wonderful flavour of the man behind the book.

    http://www.amazon.co.uk/Alfred-Watkins-Herefordshire-Ron-Shoesmith/dp/0951024272/ref=sr_1_5?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1413462748&sr=1-5

    http://www.amazon.co.uk/Alfred-Watkins-Herefordshire-Words-Photographs/dp/190666367X/ref=sr_1_7?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1413462787&sr=1-7

Leave a reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: