Book review: ‘The Scottish Malcontent’ by Colin Macaulay

The Scottish Malcontent coverIf you fancy running down the wynds of late Georgian Edinburgh in the dark, dodging musket fire and escaping through tenement windows, then The Scottish Malcontent will definitely appeal to you!

Colin Macaulay’s novel is set in 1797, a time when the republican movement of The United Scotsmen were plotting with France and the Netherlands to free their fair country of English rule.   The story centres around Aeneas Kerr, an enigmatic figure who charms his way into an old friend’s mansion and teams up with a dashing Prussian cavalry officer who is on the run and ripe for a revolution.

They are pursued by an entertaining duo in the shape of Messrs Collett and Tredwell, Officers of the King, one corpulent and world-weary, the other arrogant and impetuous.   We learn that Kerr has his own close-knit ring of contacts, each instrumental in planning an uprising that will be driven home by a much-anticipated Dutch fleet in the Firth of Forth.

While the action focuses on Kerr’s careful yet daring plot, weaving together the lives of Scotsmen who would risk their necks for independence, there is still time for humanity in the shape of George Herbertson, a surgeon whose charity leads him to tend the disease-ridden inhabitants of Edinburgh’s squalid back streets;   and for heartache, when Kerr encounters a lost love whom he should have married many years ago.

Macaulay paints a vivid picture of Edinburgh in the late 1700s:   bustling with overseas trade, expanding with new-found wealth and populated by men with proud spirits and kind hearts.  With Kerr we venture into dingy taverns, noisy steak houses and opulent drawing rooms, stroll down the fashionable Canongate and Princes’ Street, and pick our way through the sordid alleys of Leith.   The pictures are so acute and boldly drawn that you imagine the author has trodden these streets in a former life.

Will Kerr put his passion for his country before the woman he loves?   Will Herbertson’s open support of Liberty be his undoing?  And will they pull off their outrageous plan to fire the beacon on Calton Hill and attack the fort of Leith, with only a handful of stout-hearted men to support them?

Excitement, intrigue, loyalty and honour are combined with a dash of unexpected humour to produce a story that is well told and thoroughly researched;   the twist in the closing chapters is both poignant and surprising, perhaps most of all for the hapless Tredwell.

I found The Scottish Malcontent both an adventure and an education, opening my eyes to an episode in Scottish history that I confess I was unaware of.   This is a reminder that, despite the failed Jacobite rebellions, good, honest men – and women – were still ready to die for the hope of independence, even when that hope was fading to a glimmer.

‘The Scottish Malcontent’ is available as a Kindle edition from Amazon, priced at £1.99.

Comments

  1. You’ve completely sold this to me, I think I might get it for my dad for Christmas. Thank you!

  2. Paddy Meechan says:

    I need to get a copy ASAP the author is an absolute genius and a dab hand at downing a pint too.

  3. My father in law would love this, good one for christmas, thank you🙂

  4. Adding it to my ever-growing TBR list. I thank you most sincerely.

Leave a reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: